Other RPGs: A Comparison

Other RPGs: A Comparison

The world of role-playing games extends far beyond the familiar landscapes of Dungeons & Dragons. While D&D holds a dominant position, a vast and diverse ecosystem of other RPGs offers unique experiences, mechanics, and settings. This article delves into a comparative analysis of various RPG systems, exploring their core mechanics, strengths, weaknesses, and ideal player bases.

I. Narrative-Focused RPGs:

These systems prioritize storytelling and character development over complex rules. Player agency and collaborative world-building are often central themes.

• FATE: FATE uses “aspects” – short, descriptive phrases – to define characters and situations. Conflict resolution relies on rolling four Fudge dice (marked with +, -, and blank sides) and adding the result to a relevant skill. Its narrative flexibility makes it suitable for any genre and encourages improvisation. However, the lack of concrete rules can be daunting for players who prefer structured gameplay.

• Powered by the Apocalypse (PbtA): PbtA games, like Apocalypse World, Dungeon World, and Monster of the Week, focus on specific genres and playstyles. They utilize “moves,” triggered by specific actions, that dictate the narrative flow. The 2d6 system, with varying success thresholds, creates dramatic tension and emphasizes player choices. PbtA excels at creating emergent narratives but may feel restrictive to players accustomed to more character customization.

• Forged in the Dark (FitD): Inspired by Blades in the Dark, FitD games focus on crew-based gameplay, planning heists or similar operations, and dealing with the consequences. Stress and consequences play a significant role, driving the narrative forward. FitD shines in its gritty, dramatic storytelling but requires a specific type of player engagement and may not appeal to those seeking traditional character progression.

• Genesys: This narrative dice system utilizes custom dice with symbols representing success, failure, advantage, threat, triumph, and despair. The results influence the narrative rather than simply determining success or failure. Genesys offers a flexible system adaptable to various settings, but the unique dice can create a barrier to entry for some players.

II. Simulationist RPGs:

These systems aim to create a realistic or detailed simulation of a particular setting or experience. Rules are often complex and cover a wide range of situations.

• GURPS: The Generic Universal RolePlaying System is designed for adaptability, allowing players to create characters and campaigns in virtually any setting. Its point-based character creation system offers extensive customization but can be overwhelming for new players.

• RuneQuest: Focusing on Bronze Age fantasy, RuneQuest emphasizes realistic combat and detailed world-building. Its percentile system and focus on skills create a sense of grounded realism but can lead to slower character progression.

• Traveller: This science fiction RPG emphasizes exploration, trade, and interstellar travel. Character creation includes a “lifepath” system that generates a character’s background and skills, adding a unique element of randomness. Traveller provides a rich and detailed setting but can feel unforgiving to new players.

III. Traditional RPGs (Beyond D&D):

These systems share similarities with D&D in terms of core mechanics and gameplay but offer distinct settings and character options.

• Pathfinder: Building upon the D&D 3.5 edition ruleset, Pathfinder offers a wealth of character options, spells, and equipment. It provides a familiar experience for D&D players while expanding on existing content. However, its complexity can be intimidating for newcomers.

• 13th Age: This streamlined d20 system emphasizes fast-paced combat and narrative freedom. “Icons,” powerful NPCs, influence the game world and provide story hooks. 13th Age offers a dynamic and engaging experience but may lack the depth of customization found in other systems.

• Shadowrun: Blending cyberpunk and fantasy elements, Shadowrun features magic, technology, and corporate intrigue. Its complex ruleset and unique setting create a distinct atmosphere but can be challenging to learn.

IV. Indie/Alternative RPGs:

These systems often experiment with unique mechanics and explore unconventional themes.

• Lady Blackbird: This short, free RPG focuses on a small group of characters escaping a steampunk airship. Its simple rules and evocative setting make it ideal for one-shot adventures.

• Fiasco: A narrative game centered around collaborative storytelling and escalating complications, Fiasco uses dice and playsets to create humorous and often disastrous scenarios. It requires no game master and emphasizes player interaction.

• Microscope: A collaborative world-building game where players create a history spanning millennia, focusing on specific periods and events. Microscope offers a unique and engaging experience for players interested in collaborative storytelling and world-building.

V. Choosing the Right RPG:

Selecting the right RPG depends on various factors, including player preferences, desired playstyle, and preferred setting.

• Consider Your Group: Discuss preferences with your players. Do they prefer tactical combat, intricate storytelling, or collaborative world-building?

• Think About the Setting: Do you want a traditional fantasy world, a gritty cyberpunk dystopia, or something entirely unique?

• Examine the Mechanics: Do you prefer a streamlined system with simple rules or a more complex and detailed simulation?

• Start Small: Consider trying a one-shot adventure or a free quickstart guide before committing to a full campaign.

VI. Conclusion:

The world of RPGs is vast and diverse, offering a wealth of experiences beyond the familiar confines of Dungeons & Dragons. By exploring different systems and mechanics, players can discover new ways to tell stories, explore worlds, and create unforgettable characters. Whether you prefer narrative-driven gameplay, intricate simulations, or experimental indie games, there’s an RPG out there waiting to be discovered. This exploration of alternative RPGs provides a starting point for your journey into the wider world of tabletop role-playing. Remember to research, experiment, and most importantly, have fun!